About Our Products
      Back to home
      1. Help Center
      2. About Our Products

      Atlas StormMaster® Shake vs. Pinnacle® Pristine: Which Shingle is Right for You? 🏡

      Comparing Atlas' Two Most Popular Shingles for Performance, Style, and Warranty

      Overview

      When it comes to roofing shingles, Atlas Roofing offers some of the highest quality options on the market. At Liberty Roofing Pros, our two most popular shingle choices are StormMaster® Shake and Pinnacle® Pristine. Each offers excellent durability, style, and warranty coverage—but which one is right for your home?

      Let’s compare them side by side. 👇

      1. Overview of Each Shingle

      🔷 StormMaster® Shake
      A top-tier shingle designed for extreme weather conditions, perfect for Western PA homes that face hail, wind, and winter challenges.

      🔹 Pinnacle® Pristine
      A high-performance architectural shingle with advanced algae resistance and a wide selection of bold, fade-resistant colors.

      2. Warranty Comparison 📋

      Feature StormMaster® Shake Pinnacle® Pristine
      Shingle Warranty 50-Year Limited Lifetime 50-Year Limited Lifetime
      Workmanship Warranty 20 Years 15 Years
      Algae Protection Lifetime Scotchgard™ Lifetime Scotchgard™
      Wind Resistance Up to 150 mph Up to 130 mph
      Impact Rating Class 4 (highest) Standard

      🔒 Verdict: StormMaster® Shake is built for tougher weather and comes with a longer workmanship warranty.

      3. Performance Features ⚙️

      ✅ StormMaster® Shake

      • Made with SBS Modified Asphalt for flexibility and superior impact resistance.

      • Class 4 impact rating, ideal for hail-prone areas.

      • Exceptional granule adhesion for long-term protection.

      • Premium installation with Liberty’s full roofing system ensures max warranty coverage.

      ✅ Pinnacle® Pristine

      • Durable architectural design with HP42” technology for faster, cleaner installs.

      • Features Scotchgard™ Protector for long-term algae resistance.

      • Great curb appeal with consistent color and shadow lines.

      • Affordable with excellent performance for the average homeowner.

      4. Style & Aesthetics 🎨

      Both shingles are architectural (dimensional) styles that add depth and character to your roof, but differ slightly in appearance.

      StormMaster® Shake:
      🏡 Bold, rugged texture
      🎨 Richer earth-tones and high-contrast blends

      Pinnacle® Pristine:
      🏠 Sleek, modern architectural look
      🎨 Wider range of vibrant, consistent colors

      🧰 We provide full color sample kits during your consultation to match your siding, trim, and style preferences.

      5. Best Fit for Your Needs 🧭

      Choose StormMaster® Shake if you:

      • Live in a storm-prone or hail-heavy area

      • Want maximum protection and Class 4 impact resistance

      • Value a longer workmanship warranty

      • Prefer a thicker, more rugged shingle profile

      Choose Pinnacle® Pristine if you:

      • Want a beautiful, long-lasting roof on a budget

      • Don’t need impact-rated shingles

      • Want great protection from streaking and algae

      • Love the bold, clean look of designer colors

      Final Thoughts: You Can’t Go Wrong with Either ✅

      Both shingles offer long-term performance, curb appeal, and strong manufacturer backing. Our team at Liberty Roofing Pros installs both using manufacturer-approved techniques, giving you full access to all warranty benefits.

      🔹 Still not sure? Let’s walk through your options together—📞 Schedule a free estimate and see the difference in person.